One of the discussion topics that came up last Friday was the question of whether or not Benji had come of age. I'm pretty sure it was James that suggested "coming of age" is a gradual process, a series of events. I've been thinking of my own "coming of age" and what it means to me, and I've decided I quite agree with the suggestion of a gradual process.
In the last chapter, Benji may undermine some of the success and growth that he's gone through over the summer, but no matter, he's still gone through change that's made him a different person, even if it's just slightly. I feel like that's pretty similar to a "real life" coming of age process, or at least, there are parallels to my coming of age. I feel like I'm not going to have the one glorious moment like Stephen watching the bird flying, or Holden watching Phoebe on the carousel. Rather, I feel like I'm coming of age, right now, in this moment. It's a slow process, and sometimes, I don't even feel like I'm any different. But if I look back a month, two months, a year, three years, I see definite changes. Looking back, I realise how much I've grown, developed, and matured through time. I still have a ways to go (by society's standard, and personal relativity), but I think that's the point. I feel like it takes a while to realise the difference in your character, because the process is gradual and you may not even be aware that you're changing. And I'll continue to grow and change; I'll always be learning new things, and there will always be opportunities to grow and mature: become more "adult." And in a lot of years, I could be 50 and still not have my "revolutionary coming-of-age moment," but I could look back, and see how I've changed and grown, and realise that I have come of age, just slowly, gradually, and in my own time.
CONVERSATION
Subscribe to:
Post Comments
(
Atom
)
About me
Current blog for Coming of Age 2017
(Former blog for Hero's Journey 2016)
Popular Posts
-
The discussion from the first few days of class got me thinking. Heroes do play a very prevalent role in the culture our generation grew up ...
-
So, Stephen. Are you 13? 9? 16? ...does it matter? (eh not really, in my opinion). In my wonderful-but-brief time of 7th period Coming of A...
-
Ah, Odysseus. What a guy. Fagles' translation introduces Odysseus as a "man of twists and turns" (1.1.) But how does one deser...
-
And on tonight's episode of "The Good Parent," we have Ma vs the Grandparents vs Paul/Deana! Who shows Jack the "proper...
-
Confession: I didn't actually have the physical copy of Persepolis until mid this week. So, for the first few nights, I used a PDF copy...
-
"There aren't any actual swans in Black Swan Green... It's sort of a village joke" (66). hahahaha so funny! best joke I...
-
I always imagine myself in stories, and inevitably end up comparing my life to the story. For some reason, I have no trouble imagining myse...
-
On page 100, Lucille turns on the light. It's no secret that Sylvie likes to sit in the dark, even eat in the dark. Ruth even mentions ...
-
"The only trouble is, she's a little too affectionate sometimes. She's very emotional, for a child. She really is." (68, H...
-
While reading The Bell Jar , it was quite apparent, and explicitly stated, that Esther Greenwood experiences/describes parts of her life in...
Leah,
ReplyDeleteYou right you right. I feel like it's kinda like growing taller, you know? Like your grandparents will be like "omg u grew like 12cm" and you're like uhhh what no I literally look the same. I never feel like I'm getting any taller or stronger, but my brother keeps insisting that I'm catching up to him. I couldn't believe it at first -- I mean, he's the myth and the legend in terms of strength and martial tactics, but when I was put to the test... well I guess I am catching up. It's weird, growing up -- you don't feel it, but every day, you're getting closer to death. I mean uh growing up and becoming more mature and developing you're prefrontal cortex.
Some dark food for thought though -- what if I just never realize that I'm getting older, and when I'm like 70 I still do the dumb shit I do now? I'd kill myself... yea I feel like at some point I should realize how much I've grown (or regressed), or else problems will pop up.
In many ways Sag Harbor felt a lot more modern to me than some of the other stuff we've read. The coming of age moments that characters like Stephen supposedly experience seem pretty unrealistic and overly poetic/exaggerated in hindsight. There certainly are plenty of moments in all of our lives that can be considered life changing but overall I think that it is much more accurate to look at coming of age as a long process rather than a few key experiences.
ReplyDeleteI also agree that coming-of-age is not always a *spontaneous* moment where suddenly you're a man or woman. Also, in the book, Benji mentions looking back and seeing how different he was, further supporting your thoughts. Good post, Leah!
ReplyDeleteI think that you did a nice job articulating coming-of-age, and how we don't really see it happening until it is complete. But it is also interesting to consider whether that is the case, or if we are constantly evolving.
ReplyDeleteI definitely agree with you that coming of age doesn't always mean that you will have one big moment where you completely change. Instead, we are always changing in small ways, so we only notice it when we look back a year later. For this reason, Sag Harbor felt a lot more relatable to me in terms of coming of age than some of the other books we've read.
ReplyDeleteNice post. I agree with you that coming of age doesn't have a definite moment but is rather a slow change, but what I believe is that it's even more than that. I think coming of age is a cycle, something that gets repeated and never ends because you're always learning new things.
ReplyDeleteNice post Leah. I completely agree with the statement you say about not feeling like you're growing, but in fact you are. It's weird to look back and see things as "the same" when in fact they aren't quite and there's been quite a bit of change.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree that it's a gradual process. Part of "coming of age" I think is looking back and realizing you used to be less mature rather than thinking about how mature you are now (if that makes sense...). I think you will be fine, by 70 you will realize you have grown up.
ReplyDelete