While reading The Bell Jar, it was quite apparent, and explicitly stated, that Esther Greenwood experiences/describes parts of her life in relation to a bell jar. Esther has ways in which she narrates how the metaphoric bell jar changes her sensorial perceptions: by visual distortion and creating a stifling and soupy feeling/atmosphere for Esther to live and breathe.
The visual distortion plays upon both Esther and the reader. To the reader, Esther could be seen as being confined within the bell jar. Her actions, though seemingly orderly and described calmly, have an underlying sense of oddity and alarm. The way Esther narrates from within the bell jar, she depicts and describes circumstance as nothing special, just ordinary. However, she's using the bell jar's distortion to blur and shroud the unsettling events of Esther's depressive condition. On the other hand, looking from inside out of the bell jar, Esther feels as though she's watching the world with a view only she sees, and it's isolating*. Everyone sees Dodo Conway as an endearing woman with a lovely family; however, looking at Dodo through the bell jar, Esther is alone* in seeing Dodo as some grossly dehumanized fertility machine.
Esther time in the bell jar wasn't just full of "stifling distortions;" Esther describes being trapped in the bell jar full of "sour air," and equating the confinement of the bell jar to a "bad dream." In difference to distorting Esther's narrations perceptions visually, she is also physically feeling confined and stifled. The moments in which Esther feels free are when she describes being "open to the circulating air" as opposed to trapped in the "stifling air" under the bell jar.
*before meeting Dr Nolan, who shares many of the same progressive views as Esther, etc.
CONVERSATION
Subscribe to:
Post Comments
(
Atom
)
About me
Current blog for Coming of Age 2017
(Former blog for Hero's Journey 2016)
Popular Posts
-
The discussion from the first few days of class got me thinking. Heroes do play a very prevalent role in the culture our generation grew up ...
-
So, Stephen. Are you 13? 9? 16? ...does it matter? (eh not really, in my opinion). In my wonderful-but-brief time of 7th period Coming of A...
-
Ah, Odysseus. What a guy. Fagles' translation introduces Odysseus as a "man of twists and turns" (1.1.) But how does one deser...
-
And on tonight's episode of "The Good Parent," we have Ma vs the Grandparents vs Paul/Deana! Who shows Jack the "proper...
-
Confession: I didn't actually have the physical copy of Persepolis until mid this week. So, for the first few nights, I used a PDF copy...
-
"There aren't any actual swans in Black Swan Green... It's sort of a village joke" (66). hahahaha so funny! best joke I...
-
I always imagine myself in stories, and inevitably end up comparing my life to the story. For some reason, I have no trouble imagining myse...
-
On page 100, Lucille turns on the light. It's no secret that Sylvie likes to sit in the dark, even eat in the dark. Ruth even mentions ...
-
"The only trouble is, she's a little too affectionate sometimes. She's very emotional, for a child. She really is." (68, H...
-
While reading The Bell Jar , it was quite apparent, and explicitly stated, that Esther Greenwood experiences/describes parts of her life in...
I agree that Esther does a good job describing how it feels to be trapped in the Bell Jar, but it also helps to look from outside in. As you mentioned, Esther looks just as distorted from our perspective as the rest of the world looks from hers. The overall Bell Jar metaphor is very ominous, and it's not hard to see why Plath struggles with depression again given her descriptions of the looming Bell Jar.
ReplyDeleteThe "confining" nature of the bell jar metaphor also serves as a good way to illustrate that Esther can't just choose to not be depressed: the "stifling air" means that she's cut off from hope and a new worldview, and can't access the same things that everyone else can, even if she wants to.
ReplyDeleteTo me, some of the most interesting parts of the book were at the end where we learn that Esther feels like the bell jar has been momentarily lifted, allowing her to see the world as it is. She can see the emotion of things she didn't notice previously. Like earlier, it was insane to me that she didn't really care that Joan almost committed suicide only because she was inspired by Esther, but when you learn about the distortion of the bell jar it makes sense.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you, Esther's use of the bell jar is incredibly descriptive as to how she feels. The idea of being trapped behind glass, both confined, but having your view of the world warped, aligns with her description of her experience incredibly well.
ReplyDeleteYeah, I think a really good example of the reader's understanding of Esther under the bell jar is the scene with the hamburger meat and egg. Esther, as we look into the bell jar from outside, is doing something incredibly bizarre and grotesque. Yet, she mentions her meal in such a nonchalant way that the reader can tell there's something off with her, and can see the distorted way she's acting clear as day.
ReplyDeleteNot only does the bell jar affect Esther's view of Dodo Conway, it affects the view she has of herself as well. There are several times throughout the book where Esther looks in the mirror and sees a monster where she her own face should be. The ever-present distortion is severely affecting her self esteem in how she believes she looks to the outside world.
ReplyDeleteI really like this post. I think you do a great job of describing Esther in the Bell Jar. Her vision of the world is distorted and I think Plath does a really good job of describing it. I think it presents to the reader a good description of mental illness, even though they will obviously never really understand what it is like.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you in the fullest Leah! I also appreciate how the word "Bell Jar" in your post actually leads to a picture, reminding us what a bell jar is actually like. Like you said, in the bell jar she's exposed to her own reality -- things such as eating raw beef with raw eggs seem like a normality that she can tell us like it's just another day (and for her, it really is). Through these actions instead of "just talk", Esther gives us a better feel of what her depression is like. That's what made me realize another reason why depression is so bad -- the person depressed isn't aware that they are doing anything out of the ordinary. I can image Joan just being like "meh, I guess I'll go kill myself after this cup of tea". That's just deeply disturbing for me.
ReplyDeleteIm just coming back to this blog post and its interesting to look back on it after having some time away from the novel and Esther. It is especially interesting to compare the bell jar to some of the other characters (in other books) traps and ways that they deal with being confined. Esther definitely came out and made hers more obvious, but it seems as if all of the characters can empathize with such feelings.
ReplyDeleteLike everyone else, I agree with your post as well. When Esther tells us about the "bell jar", it allows us to understand why she views the world as she does. Otherwise, to readers like us who aren't in the bell jar, her attitudes towards things such as having children may seem extremely odd.
ReplyDelete